For men of a certain age, a crisp polo shirt with a 1¼-inch green crocodile emblem fixed proudly to the chest was a uniform suitable for both shenanigans as a youth and adult hijinks in the contemporary. As The Washington Post noted in 1977 of the timelessness of the animal-inspired crest, “It is, perhaps, the longest-running status clothing item for men.”

But depending on when and where you grew up, the right reptile on one’s chest is a major point of contention – with intertwined histories often just as murky as the inhabited bodies of water of the animals of which they’re based upon.

To some, Parisian brand, Lacoste, is the one true sauropod – perhaps evidenced by Supreme’s willingness and desire to work with the brand on a fall/winter collection.

Others feels strongly that American-made brand, Izod, should be the only company that can take credit for the crocodile’s importance in sartorial history. This ethos relies instead on pervasiveness of wear as opposed to what brand actually came first.

Or is it possible that both camps could be right; with a third crocodile with Asian origins that has equal claims to prodigiousness of the iconography?

Lacoste S.A.

René Lacoste – of whom the eponymous label is named for – was a storied French tennis player in the 1920s who earned Grand Slam victories at the French Open, Wimbledon, and U.S. Open and not surprisingly rose to become the top ranked player in the entire world in 1926 and 1927.

In total, he won 10 majors (seven singles, three doubles) before his career was cut short due to tuberculosis.

Lacoste S.A.

Lacoste earned himself an unlikely nickname – “The Alligator” – after making a wager with the French Davis Cup captain at the time, Alan Muhr. Simply put, if Lacoste won his match that evening, Muhr would be on the hook for purchasing an alligator-skin suitcase that had caught Lacoste’s eye during an evening stroll.

Although Lacoste lost that evening, American journalist, George Carens, heard the story about the wager and mentioned it in his article in the Boston Evening Transcript, writing, “The young Lacoste has not won his crocodile skin suitcase but he fought like a true crocodile.”

Lacoste embraced the nickname, saying “the nickname highlighted my tenacity on the tennis courts, never giving up my prey.”

When he returned to France, “alligator” became “crocodile,” and Lacoste was known forever after as “the Crocodile.”

Getty

Whereas “branding” is every bit as important as execution is for today’s athlete, sportsmen and women of the Roaring 20’s weren’t accustomed to nor expected to stand out from that of their competition. Specifically, tennis – known for its cumbersome “tennis white” uniform which consisted of long-sleeves, long pants and tie – was decidedly bland and not exactly sporty.

Lacoste looked to advance both the sport and his own personal image by challenging the status quo. He believed that a variation on the knit preferred by Indian polo players’ uniforms would allow for “functional elegance” in his own discipline.

“One day I noticed my friend the Marquis of Cholmondeley wearing his polo shirt on the court,” Lacoste told People Magazine. ”‘A practical idea,’ I thought to myself.'”

Lacoste S.A.

The same year that Lacoste won the U.S. Open, he debuted an embroidered logo of his “crocodile” moniker that was created by his friend, Robert George, who would later have a Lacoste collection bear his name in tribute.

It is often believed that this emblem was one of first commercial logos designed for display – perhaps second only to Jantzen swimwear’s logo of a woman in a diving posture wearing a red, one-piece swimsuit and bathing cap.

Lacoste’s crocodile polo was an instaneous hit – both with sportsmen and the fashion elite – and he knew that he had the potential to set up an endeavor for his post-tennis life.

Lacoste S.A.

In turn, he partnered with André Gillier, president of the largest French knitwear company at the time, to manufacturer crocodile-laden polo shirts (la chemise Lacoste) – featuring a turndown collar, three buttons on its placket, and a breathable piqué-cotton body – to the masses.

“For me this company was a Saturday afternoon hobby and a way to invent things,” said Lacoste.

Lacoste S.A.

Whereas we think of polo-style shirts in a rainbow of colors these days, Lacoste can take credit for infusing these vivid pantones into the style.

Terapeak

In the late ’30s, Lacoste then stuck up a venture with Vincent De Paul Draddy, president of David Crystal Inc, to license his shirts in the United States.

The name “Izod” itself was based upon Arthur James “Jack” Izod – an acclaimed London tailor – whose wears were held in such high regard that the Prince of Wales commissioned him to make shirts for the royal household.

“Can you imagine that at the time I considered not bothering with the alligator symbol?” Draddy remembered.

The most notable distinction between the French version and American version of the crocodile polo was that the latter had a longer shirttail in the back.

However minute the changes actually were, the Lacoste family was not impressed.

“The French preferred an even hemline that looked neat when worn outside the pants,” explained Bernard Lacoste, son of René Lacoste. “Besides, the American man has a longer torso and needs the longer length.”

For the better part of a decade, Izod Lacoste imported an all-cotton version of the polo while manufacturing a poly-cotton blend of their own Stateside.

However, the brand dropped the imported version in the early 1970s when the price of cotton, dyes and labor increased.

Despite the growing division between the Parisian and American entities, business was officially booming.

Getty

By 1979, combined sales for both styles was $350 million USD – with half coming from the American market where President Dwight Eisenhower, Bob Hope and John Wayne had popularized the trend. This adoration amongst the American elite is a major reason why generations of American kids believed that Izod was responsible for the crocodile trend.

In an interview with Associated Press, René Lacoste seemed at a loss to explain the popularity of his emblem throughout the world.

“There are kinds of things that just don’t have any good explanation,” he said. “I suppose you could say that if it had been a really nice animal, something sympathetic, then maybe nothing would have happened. Suppose I had picked a rooster. Well, that’s French, but it doesn’t have the same impact.”

In 1993, Crystal Brands Inc. – citing a cash shortage – sold 50 percent interest in Lacoste Alligator S.A. for $31.5 million USD to Sporloisirs S.A., which already owned the other half.

Cilory

One could make the argument that no one truly owns the crocodile emblem.

In 2003, Hong Kong sportswear company, Crocodile Garments – who had earned a trademark for their Lacoste/Izod-esque crocodile design in the 1950s after Tan Hiantsin registered it in Singapore – found themselves embroiled in a legal dispute over trademark infringement with Lacoste.

Ultimately, the brand decided to tweak its logo slightly as part of the settlement – choosing a croc with a vertically-raised tale, scaly skin and bigger eyes than Lacoste’s version.

Getty

In Woody Allen’s short story “The Scrolls,” he famously wrote about a shirt salesman who had fallen on hard times.

When he asks God for help, he gets a divine response: “Put an alligator over the pocket. Just do what I’m telling you. You won’t be sorry.”

Bernard Lacoste seems to believe something similar, stating “I think it has become something mythical.”

What To Read Next