Double Tap to Zoom

It's official: The Great Greenwashing Crackdown is coming for beauty. Mega-retailer Sephora is facing a class-action lawsuit for allegedly engaging in false advertising via its collection of "clean" beauty products.

Plaintiff Lindsey Finster has taken issue with the cosmetic giant's Clean at Sephora initiative, a section of its website reserved for products it denotes as clean, or "formulated without parabens, sulfates SLS and SLES, phalates, mineral oils, formaldehyde, and more."

Your Highsnobiety privacy settings have blocked this Instagram post.

According to Finster, this definition of clean is at odds with several of products that Sephora sells under the Clean at Sephora banner: "A significant percentage of products with the ‘Clean At Sephora’ [label] contain ingredients inconsistent with how consumers understand this term," she argues.

To illustrate her point, Finster refers to a specific product, Saie's Mascara 101, that Sephora labels as clean but "contains numerous synthetic ingredients...  several of which have been reported to cause possible harms."

Finster's case illustrates lack of regulation regarding the term "clean," its use, and its definition. "If you ask 10 different people what clean beauty means, you’ll get 10 different answers," skinfluencer Caroline Hirons told The New York Times in a recent interview on the slippery slope that is clean beauty.

Your Highsnobiety privacy settings have blocked this Instagram post.

Similarly, brands and retailers vary in their definition of "sustainable" or "ethical" fashion, often employing the word to advertise items or collections that may not meet an individual consumer's standards for sustainability or ethics.

Last July, H&M was named as the defendant in a lawsuit claiming the retailer "created an extensive marketing scheme to ‘greenwash’ its products." The following month, fast fashion giants Boohoo and Asos found themselves at the center of an investigation for sustainability claims.

As Finster v. Sephora takes center stage, it seems that "clean beauty" — whatever that means —  is facing a similar reckoning.

We Recommend
  • These Are Niche Perfume Brands You Need to Know in Spring 2026
  • A Man’s Medicine Cabinet Is the Last Honest Place on Earth
  • AXE Is All Grown Up & Noses Everywhere Are Safer for It
  • NIOD Wants to Depollute Your Face
What To Read Next
  • Vans' Pretty Cow-Patterned Skate Shoe Brings Farm to Skatepark
  • The adidas Samba Mary Jane Gets Serious About Its Ballet Sneaker Era
  • New Balance's All-American Dad Shoe Finds Beauty in the Dark
  • Sashiko Stitching Brought These Artful Jordan Sneakers to Life
  • Nike’s Red-Hot Shox Ballerina Sneaker Is Just Warming Up
  • Nike’s Mesh-tastic High-Tech Air Max Is Set to Summer Mode